2005 – Roland Savoie – Bethany

            Lee Lovel – Church in the Acres      

2006 – Ken Butcher – Foster Memorial

            Dan Darcy – First Central

2007 – Bob Hoyt – Heritage

            Bob Moore – Union

2008 – Bryan Olden – Tabernacle

            Joe Trevathan – First Central

2009 – Harry Reimers – Bethlehem

            Glenn Gilbert – Bethany

2010 – Tom Butcher – Foster Memorial / Trinity

            John Demaria – Church in the Acres

2011 – Henry Ramsey – Christian Life Center

            Jeff Frazee – Bethany

2012 – Ven Grumoli – Nazarene / Christ Presbyterian

             Brenden Grant – First Central

2013 – Roger Coughlin – Heritage / Church in the Acres

            Bill Pass – Church of Redemption

2014 – Brian Whitacre – Tabernacle / LifePoint

            Stan Kulig – First Central

2015 – Steve Chisholm – Trinity

            Joe Ruiz – Bethany

2016 – Don Garden – Bethlehem

            Pastor Brian Macleod – Bethlehem

2017- Eric Martin – First Central

          Fran Lapa – Christ Life Fellowship

2018 – Mike Naglieri – Foster Memorial

            Pat Defalco – Church of Christ

2019 – Chris Pyrek – Redemption

            Phil Bonk – Bethany Assembly

2020 – No All Star Game

2021 – Karl Hulseberg – Redemption

            Barry Andrusik – Sonlife

2022 – Diane Lussier – Christ Community

            Nikali Benkert – Christ Presbyterian

2024 – Pat Warner – First Central/Bethany

Tex Kennedy – Foster Memorial